Diskusia:Štefan I. (Uhorsko)

Zdroje

Pri všetkej úcte k snahe autorov, ale takýto článok s takouto témou musí mať uvedené aspoň nejaké zdroje alebo referencie. Najmä ak je pomerne obsiahly.--Skorpix 21:31, 13. október 2010 (UTC)

Historical inaccuracies

Dear Slovak Wikipedia! I took the liberty to translate this page into English. The article is full of historical inaccuracies but let me just address two of them to highlight how unreliable it is. First, it is claimed in the article that during the rebellion of Koppány Stephen fled to Nitra. In fact, however, he immediately marched against Koppány near Veszprém and defeated and killed him in one battle. As a matter of fact Pázmány and Hont were of german origin. Second, the coins with PRESLAVVA CIV are not thought to have been minted in Bratislava. Přerov or Břeclav are more likely candidates, maybe as a result of territorial conquest with the Holy Roman Empire in the 1030s. Given that only a handful of copies exist from this type, as opposed to around 50 from the LANCEA REGIS and thousands from the second type of Stephen's coins, it is even more likely that this coin was struck for a brief period of time, strengthening the location of today's Czech Republic.

Actually, your information also does not have necessary citations but I include mine. It's up to you whether you revise the article but thank God the international community reads the English one.

Let me just cite two articles, for the second you can also take the liberty to translate into your own language:

https://publikace.nm.cz/en/file/b0f1ad3b796e3f2bb9d12134c312a6a5/15823/Sbornik%20A%201-2_6_gedai.pdf

http://epa.oszk.hu/01400/01445/00019/pdf/EPA01445_acta_hungarica_2016_5_0686-0707.pdf --Ignotvs (diskusia) 11:38, 8. august 2023 (UTC)

Falsification of History

Vajk, the pagan name with the Turkic origin is nowhere mentioned to be a Slavic one on the Hungarian and on the English wiki, not even as a possibility, but on the Slovak page. The idea is ridiculous. It tries to slovakize Hungarian history, when if the Hungarian ruling dynasty had any non-christian names, they were old-hungarian. --2001:4C4E:2609:3500:830:39B6:11FA:F024 14:26, 25. marec 2024 (UTC)